Bill Approved to Expedite a Successor
to Kennedy
Published: September 22, 2009, New York Times
BOSTON —Fulfilling one of Edward
M. Kennedyfs dying wishes, the Massachusetts State Senate approved a bill on
Tuesday allowing a temporary replacement for the late senator.
Michael S. Dukakis, left, was said to be out of the running for
Edward M. Kennedyfs Senate seat, while Paul G. Kirk Jr., right, a former aide to
Mr. Kennedy, was said to be a likely choice.
The measure was pushed through by the Democratic leadership in an effort to
deliver what might be a crucial vote when health care overhaul legislation comes
before Congress this fall. Mr. Kennedy had made health reform one of his
lifetime priorities.
The vote in the State Senate, 24 to 16, means that Gov. Deval
Patrick could appoint an interim senator within days.
In Washington, aides said that Senator Harry
Reid of Nevada, the majority leader, pumped his fist after a note about the
Massachusetts vote was passed to him in his conference room.
Mr. Patrick, a Democrat who is close to President
Obama, has refused to discuss potential appointees, but senior Democrats in
Washington said Tuesday that Paul G. Kirk Jr., a former aide to Mr. Kennedy and
chairman of the Democratic
National Committee, was a likely choice.
The Democrats, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said they believed that
Michael
S. Dukakis, the former governor and 1988 presidential nominee, said to be
under consideration, was out of the running and would not be named.
Other possibilities include Evelyn Murphy, a former lieutenant governor; and
Charles Ogletree, a professor at Harvard
Law School.
A spokesman for Mr. Patrick, Kyle Sullivan, would not discuss a timeframe for
an appointment, saying only that the governor was pleased with the vote.
The appointee would take Mr. Kennedyfs place in the Senate only until a
special election is held Jan. 19 but could play a critical role in Congressional
Democratsf efforts in the coming months.
gIt means that Massachusetts will be represented by two senators in one of
the most important debates of our times,h said Senator Richard
J. Durbin of Illinois, the No. 2 Democrat in the Senate, referring to the
health care fight.
Democrats in Washington were not willing to publicly discuss whether they had
a preference for the interim appointee. But some party officials said concerns
had been raised privately about the prospect of Mr. Dukakis taking the seat,
saying he was a reminder of an era of Democratic failure. They also worried that
Mr. Dukakis, 75, might exhibit an independent streak when their main goal at the
moment is to hold Democrats as a bloc.
But an editorial in The
Boston Globe on Tuesday said Mr. Dukakis would be the best choice, saying
that he gknows how politics works and can get his phone calls returned.h
Some Democrats said that appointing Mr. Kirk, now the chairman of the John
F. Kennedy Library Foundation in Boston, would make sense because of his
close ties to the Kennedy family.
Even as Democrats moved toward filling the Kennedy vacancy, the health
problems of another senator resurfaced, a reminder of the precariousness of the
partyfs hold on 60 votes. Senator Robert
C. Byrd, 91, Democrat of West Virginia, suffered a fall at his Virginia home
on Tuesday and was hospitalized. Aides said he was being kept in the hospital as
a precautionary measure.
In Massachusetts, where the succession measure won passage in the House of
Representatives last week, the floor debate focused on the complaint of
Republicans, and even some Democrats, that the bill was overly partisan.
Governors here had the power to fill Senate vacancies until 2004, when the
Democratic majority in the legislature changed the law to require a special
election. Democrats worried then that if Senator John
Kerry were elected president, Gov. Mitt
Romney, a Republican, would appoint a Republican.
gAny way you slice it,h Senator Richard Tisei, the Senate minority leader,
said of the bill, gitfs bad precedent and bad politics.h
All 5 Republicans and 11 Democrats opposed the measure. Therese Murray, the
Senate president, remained publicly noncommittal until just before the vote,
despite calls from the Obama administration and from Victoria
Reggie Kennedy, Mr. Kennedyfs widow. Ms. Murray ultimately supported the
measure.
The bill does not prohibit the temporary appointee from seeking Mr. Kennedyfs
seat in the special election — legislators feared that such a condition would
not pass constitutional muster — but Mr. Patrick has said he would ask the
appointee to promise not to run.
New laws normally cannot take effect in Massachusetts for 90 days, but
governors can put them into effect immediately by declaring an emergency. The
bill must be put to a final procedural vote in both chambers of the legislature
on Wednesday before being sent to Mr. Patrick.
Under current law, Mr. Kennedyfs seat would remain empty until the special
election in January. But shortly before he died of brain cancer last month, Mr.
Kennedy asked the state legislature to change the law and allow Mr. Patrick to
name a temporary successor until the special election could be held.
Senator Robert A. OfLeary, a Democrat who represents Mr. Kennedyfs home town
of Hyannis, appealed to his colleagues to approve the measure out of respect for
the late senator.
gI for one think that is something we need to honor,h he
said.
Abby Goodnough reported from Boston and Carl Hulse from Washington; Katie
Zezima contributed reporting from
Boston.
A version of this article appeared in print on September 23, 2009,
on page A14 of the New York edition.